Article written by Karthik S

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention Will you file a police complaint against your employer? | Beast of Traal -- Topsy.com

  • http://www.mindstrategist.com V Gangan

    1. I have worked in the western world as well as in India, and I had goose bumps reading this story. Good on Mr Desai to take up the larger cause, which could mean that he might lose favour with his bosses, if not his job. I agree with Mr Desai, that safety concerns are given a priority in the west, but not in India. I hope his efforts result in improved Health and Safety conditions not just at Oracle (assuming they are lacking), but also in other workplaces where such conditions are so common that employees hardly notice them.
    2. If I was Oracle’s internal comms advisor, I would have discouraged Mr Desai from discussing his concerns in a staff newsletter. Instead, I would have encouraged thos to be discussed directly with the management, which he did. Staff newsletters are not designed to criticise poor working conditions.
    3. If I was Oracle’s external comms advisor, I would suggest one of the two options – A. If the company was taking concrete steps to comply with H&S, then issue a media statement ASAP outlining the exact steps proposed; B. If there is not much the company need to do, or can do or intends to do, then I would let the story die its natural death.
    In my PR career, I strived to make company spokespersons available, especially for issues-based stories, such as this one. However, there are rare occasions when no response is the best response.

    • http://itwofs.com/beastoftraal/ Karthik Srinivasan

      Gangan: Very good observations in your comment.

      On the tactic to ‘review’ the fire safety systems in the building, in the internal newsletter, I do not know the circumstances that led him to do that. Did he try direct engagement with the right people in the senior management and did this as a last resort to build support from others? I do not know, but yes, at he outset, that seems like a counterproductive tactic.

      On your suggestion (B)…considering this story is out in the media and more importantly, in the police station, I’m not sure if they can expect it to die down. I’ll be checking online forums and groups to see if there is any whisper about this from other Oracle employees…just to see how much of this has resonated internally.

  • Sharandesai

    I personally thank you all so much for your support …. Sharan Desai

  • Gurumart

    One need to actually check out Sharan. He is a very insecure and egoistical individual. He is riding on Safety and Security of employees potraying himself to be a martyr, in fact he has never hit it off with his colleagues, always in trouble and has been in a rut from the time he has joined the organisation. So he resorts to exaggeration and sensationalism … His motive is not right and that is why he will not gain much from this. Oracle has confidence in its systems, and core values, they are not even shaken a little bit…poor chap needs counselling. Do a google search on Sharan Desai he is an old crook or raking up issues and has never been successful. His various PR stunts for the city of Gulbarga are a flop with no one even reading his articles.. by the way this building is a 3 storied building, not a high raised one as exaggerated by Desai…

    • Ramesh Kumar

      The
      FIR, registered on Saturday, names OFSS managing director and CEO Chaitanya
      Kamat, senior VP and general manager Frank Brienzi, HR business partner Tonya
      Holck, HR director Sajan Mathai, senior VP (HR) Vivek Govilker and HR head
      (Bangalore and Chennai) K K Davis. In a suo motu complaint lodged by police
      sub-inspector Hariyappa, the six have been charged under section 112 of the
      Karnataka Police Act, which states that any person not obeying regulatory
      orders may be arrested and, on conviction by a court, shall be liable to pay a
      fine. Any apparatus or equipment used in such violations shall also be liable
      for confiscation.

      The FIR was registered after the cops failed to elicit a response from OFSS
      executives in connection with a complaint filed by the company’s own employee
      Sharan Desai about the shortcomings in the fire safety systems in the
      building. 

      Hello Mr. GURUMART,
      read the content – I guess you your just a pimp (Prostitute’s manager) to
      Oracle Corporation Management, you lick anything to survive – good luck with
      your new job 

    • Sharandesai

      6 Oracle execs get summons over fire safety

      Police say firm has not produced any document to counter charges
              

      The Metropolitan Magistrate Court has issued summons to six top executives of Oracle Financial Software Services (OFSS), including its CEO, after the Mahadevapura police filed a chargesheet against them with regard to lapses in fire safety at the company’s premises.  ‘It’s like sitting on a ticking time bomb’

      The police had filed a chargesheet on February 17 under Section 112 of Karnataka Police Act, which says any person not obeying the regulatory orders may be arrested and on conviction by a court of law, shall be liable for fine, and any apparatus or equipment used in such violation shall be liable for confiscation. Cops get tough with Oracle  
       
      Sharan Desai, an employee of Oracle, had raised the issue of fire safety at the company’s premises at Millennium Tower on Kundanahalli Road.
       
      Bangalore Mirror had published a story titled It’s like sitting on a ticking time bomb on Feb 10, 2011. Following the report, Desai’s services were terminated and he later filed an FIR against his seniors.
       
      The police have chargesheeted OFSS managing director and CEO Chaitanya Kamat, senior VP and general manager Frank Brienzi, HR business partner Tonya Holck, HR director Sajan Mathai, senior VP (HR) Vivek Govilker and HR head (Bangalore and Chennai) K K Davis.
       
      Mahadevapura police inspector K S Nagaraj said, “We booked a case because the company had allegedly not followed fire safety stipulations and has so far not produced any documents to counter the allegations. During investigation, it was found it had failed to take care of its employees’ safety.”
       
      He said police have filed a chargesheet and the court has issued summons to six OFSS executives.
       
      Desai said, “After I raised the issue, I was terminated for which I am fighting a case in the labour court. But the complaint forced the company to shift its office. Some people from the company are trying to reach me for negotiation, but I haven’t shown any interest.”
       
      He said the case is in labour court, “which clearly says I am still an employee of Oracle. After the court’s order, I would love to join the company”.

  • Sharan Desai

    Gurumart has commented using Sundar Murthy at Bangalore Mirror onlinel site. He must have got paid for his BS comment. This building is not 3 stories. It is ground + 4 (according to BBMP it is a high rise). I have provided the Fire Safety Violations facts in detail. I have submitted 8 documents with 78 pages with photographs evidence to Oracle and Oracle Corporation has failed to investigate the matter in detail. If Sundar Murthy wants meet me in person at OFSS MT office, I will educate and show him employee safety violations of OFSS MT location. I would ask him to be sure about his name first before talking BS about other.

  • Gurumart

    I have checkd with sharan desai’s colleagues. he has worked 11+ years in the organisation. ask him to show his achievements. NIL or insignificant. Check his past appraisals – average or below average performer. You will see the problems with this individual. he wants to hit out at his colleagues and is using the firesafety as an issue. 99% of the staff have ignored his drama and are comfortable with the building, they will also stand and give witness that they are not unsafe or insecure of the fire safety features in the building. Signature campaign is on. Sharan …if you have issues with your work and your supervisors you should address it to the point not create a grand movie nobody of the 1000 ppl you claim you are fighting for will stand by you…they will counter your claim of an insafe building.

  • Ramesh Raddi

    I was shocked and surprised to find what happened and its truly commendable as no one comes ahead to raise voice against such giant corporates. It’s true that their development centers outside India are well equipped with all possible safety measures. Ignoring the same fact and basic safety need in India is not acceptable.
    Recently one of our customer put all the travels on hold as the facility to which team were supposed to travel was not certified yet for fire safety. People those didn’t respond to you properly and ask you to cease, are also Indians, they shouldn’t have done that. Instead of all this they should have ensured safety of employees who are backbone of any organization.
    Indians are used to live with problems and we are proudly used to it. This makes others to make USE of us.I fully support what you did

  • Sharandesai
  • Sharandesai

    Please read article ‘Life’s now safer for 1,200 Oracle employees’ in today’s (March 21, 2011) @ 2nd page

    http://www.bangaloremirror.com/article/10/20110321201103210006534871b72620e/Life%E2%80%99s-now-safer-for-1200-Oracle-employees.html

  • Sharandesai

    _http://www.bangaloremirror.com/article/10/20110321201103210006534871b72620e/Life%E2%80%99s-now-safer-for-1200-Oracle-employees.html

  • Sharan Desai

    I personally, thank Karthik S, Ramesh Raddi, Resmi Writer, V gangan, Karthik Srinivasan, Shivangiyadav, Beastoftraal, Harmanjit, Priyankawriting and StrategyDigital
    for your time and support.

    Most of us tend to react swift when disaster strikes, the Carlton Towers accident was a big example of not following safety precautions, the lesson that I have learnt after the major fire incident at Carlton Towers at Bangalore’s is to look around for the safety measures and raise the employee safety concerns, however it was never easy for me as I go through emotional distress by the management treatment.

  • Sharandesai