Taran’s digs on Naachgaana, hastey hastey!

3 Comments »

New to Milliblog? If you like what you read here, may I suggest subscribing to Milliblog's RSS feed or e-mail alerts?. Thanks for visiting!

Taran Adarsh’s review of the film, Hastey hastey takes his personal animosity towards Naachgaana founder Rohit Karan Batra to new heights when he writes in the second sentence of his review, “The story idea, credited to one Rohit Batra, is so tacky, so banal, so obsolete, so lifeless that you break into a big yawn 10 minutes into the film”. Naachgaana is a regular bashing ground for all things Taran, but there are balanced voices too. The film may be terrible, but this personal dig is in very poor taste, given Taran Adarsh’s standing in India, regardless of his reviews.

Keywords: Rohit Karan Batra, Naachgaana, Taran Adarsh, IndiaFM, Bollywood Hungama

Singh is Kinng. Yeah right, but who’s the composer?

8 Comments »

“Music rights of `Singh is Kinng’ sold at Rs 13.5 cr” proclaims a DNA story yesterday. Amidst all the hoopla created by the Times Group since they’ve purchased the music rights for that humongous amount, there’s not one word on who the composer is! There are mentions of Akshay Kumar’s box office draw, Times Music having tasted success with ‘Welcome’ (!!?) and that they will monetize the music of this film in multiple ways. Folks…you forgot the most critical part of a soundtrack - the composer! This is a terrible trend and perhaps points to a multi-composer nonsense like Welcome.

Keywords: Vipul Shah, Akshay Kumar, Katrina Kaif, Neha Dhupia

Sony BMG’s extraordinarily shoddy piece of work!

No Comments »

Sony BMG’s latest release, the OST for the Pakistani film, Khuda Ke Liye, is perhaps the worst soundtrack I’ve seen yet from an international record label. I’m talking about the credits – there’s none! I wish they showed enough zeal in adding the name of composers/ singers/ lyricists as much as they did in adding ring tone codes. This soundtrack was out, outside India, mid last year – meaning, more time to get complete credits. The only two music-related credits include ‘AKS’ for arranging ‘Bandya’ and Rohail Hyatt for background music. This is irresponsible and a serious insult to the concerned artists.

Now that there’s at least one Orkut group that seems to have completely mis-read this post of mine, let me try and clear the air. When I say, ‘worst soundtrack’ I’m NOT commenting on the music. I’m referring to the fact that Sony has omitted credit to Pakistani artists who deserve their names in the CD when it is released in India. The Indian CD released by Sony BMG does not list any singer/ composer for individual songs. The point is that Sony BMG is so damn careful to include mobile ring tone download codes but have forgotten to add the most important part of an audio CD - who composed the songs? And who sang them. So, khuda ke liye, please read the post properly!

Will Daniel B. George please fight for his rights?

2 Comments »

Daniel…who? Daniel B. George is perhaps the rightful owner of the title credits for Johnny Gaddaar’s soundtrack. Shankar Ehsaan Loy have to their credit just three tracks – not counting the vernacular variants. Daniel is the man behind 5 tracks, followed by 2 for DJ Shane and 1 by Gulraj Singh. I recall seeing almost every review (including mine!) attributing the entire OST to the trio thanks to an amazingly ‘designed’ album sleeve! Besides the fact that I didn’t really enjoy this soundtrack, I think its maha-unfair to Daniel, who’s only other known work is Kabeer Kaushik’s ‘Sehar’ (2005).

The ‘real’ track list of Johnny Gaddaar, with the composers’ names against each track!
01. Johnny Gaddaar - Shankar Ehsaan Loy
02. Move your body - Shankar Ehsaan Loy
03. Dhoka - Shankar Ehsaan Loy
04. Johnny in the house - DJ Shane
05. Move your body (Phatt Mix) - DJ Shane
06. Johnny breakbeat mear naam - Gulraj Singh
07. Revenge of the 70s (Instrumental) - Daniel B. George
08. The caper begins (Instrumental) - Daniel B. George
09. Toss (Instrumental) - Daniel B. George
10. Confidence (Instrumental) - Daniel B. George
11. Bhule bisre geet - Daniel B. George
12. Johnny Gaddaar (Tamil) - Shankar Ehsaan Loy
13. Move your body (Tamil) - Shankar Ehsaan Loy
14. Johnny Gaddaar (Telugu) - Shankar Ehsaan Loy
15. Move your body (Telugu) - Shankar Ehsaan Loy

Jana gana mana and a few retarded opinions

8 Comments »

I had talked about Rahman and Bharatbala leveraging the sheer musical value of our national anthem, recently. It has now taken a ridiculous turn with a Chennai-based retired inspector filing a PIL against Rahman and Airtel’s Sunil Mittal. One of the complaints seem to be, “when this ‘remix’ was telecast, viewers were in various positions and thus unable to pay respect due prescribed…This amounts to dishonoring the anthem”. Holy crap! Apart from the fact that the anthem requires our respect from our heart, than the feet, the point behind honoring it when played should be linked to the circumstances and surroundings in which it is being played. If there’s a protocol that everytime the anthem enters your aural range you are supposed to stand still to respect it, I personally feel that such a protocol is completely beyond the scope of common sense. Hey, I’m crossing the road and the school on the opposite side starts playing the anthem just as I’m rushing away from a speeding lorry. So, I suppose I will die a martyr, huh? I’m utterly surprised that my joke of standing everytime the telly plays Rahman’s version is considered seriously enough worth a PIL!

Note: This PIL has been thrown out of the window by the court. Deservedly so!

15 years of A.R.Rahman’s music - 1992 to 2007 and continuing!

49 Comments »

I still remember August 15, 1992. I was at school, pretty annoyed at the Independence Day routine while the rest of the world was glued to the telly, watching the then-favorite, Oliyum Oliyum (OO), the default program for new Tamil film songs - the Tamil equivalent of Chitrahaar. An August 15th OO means brand new songs, films of which may have been released that day. As I finished the school’s flag hoisting ceremony and entered home, OO was long over. I checked with my Mom if there was anything striking among the songs played that morning. She vaguely recalled some interesting song starring unknown faces and a strangely alien but alluring sound.

That was ‘Chinna chinna aasai’ from Roja. My first brush with Rahman’s music on screen was ‘Kaadhal rojave’ that was aired in the subsequent week’s OO! And, I was captivated by the sheer difference in everything from vocals, the choice of instruments…the overall sound. It was excitingly fresh, unlike anything I’ve ever heard before.

Pudhiya mugam, Gentleman, May Madham…one by one Rahman delivered some mind bogglingly varied tracks that only increased my interest in his music. I finally had someone who’s music I can rush and buy on the day its released. I still remember bunking college to get my hands on the first tape of Kaadhalan. Or the days we used to annoy our lecturer by humming the prominent hmmm portion in Kaadhalan’s ‘Kaadhalikkum pennin’. Or even the first time I heard ‘Hello hello premalekha’ on Zee TV’s limited Telugu feeds on weekday evenings and instinctively guessed that it has to be Rahman. Since I could not find Gang Master in the shops in my city, I had to ask one of my pen-friends (found via Target!) in Chennai to send me the tape. She sent me a double-film tape that had Gang Master and Super Police, the two of the only four direct Telugu films by Rahman (the other two being Naani and Nee manasu naaku telusu - Naani was made in Tamil as New, while the latter was dubbed as Enakku 20 Unakku 18)!

I joined my first job in Delhi and besides the minimal internet access in my PG, got my first exposure to full fledged internet at office! And the first thing that struck me was that there was no single, online source for Rahman’s songs. Thus started arrmp3, hosted at Geocities. It was, at that point, perhaps one of the most comprehensive audio destinations for Rahman’s songs and included rare tracks, latest interviews et all…updated at amazing speed! Geocities used to frown at mp3s back then and I had to break each mp3 into 4-5 pieces, rename them as jpg/ gif and upload them. Geocities usually yanked these too and I had, at one point, as many as 80+ Geocities accounts, since each account gave me just 20MB!

My interest in his music gradually came down to more earthly levels, from the initial, literal worship as time progressed and I gave up on arrmp3 too, shortly, as a result. I moved on to creating the plagiarism-tracking website, I2FS (or ItwoFS!), back in 2000 and decided that I need to distance myself from the online image of being a devoted fan of one composer, so that people assume that I2FS is being managed without any bias. But people continue to ask me why Indian’s ‘Telephone manipol’ and its so-called original by Ace of Base (All that she wants) is not listed yet. I’ve responded to perhaps 500 odd mails on this topic and continue to refuse spending anymore time on this non-issue.

There have been so many new composers who have been influenced, either directly or indirectly by Rahman, but Rahman himself has evolved significantly over the years. He perhaps reserves his most creative work for Maniratnam and Shankar, but has gone on to deliver gems in other directors’ films too. His current music is perhaps far removed from his initial repertoire, from an instantly appealing sound to a more mature, evolved sound that people tend to listen multiple times before they can grasp the nuances and start appreciating it.

But, the music landscape is a lot more competitive now and Rahman, though a pioneer at one point, is, for me, just one more better peddler of the mod, new, filmi sound. The truth however, is that no other composer, post Rahman, has excited me to that extent. It was also probably because of the limited choice we had at that time and that I was personally witnessing a gradual decline in my all time favorite composer’s (Ilayaraja) body of work.

These days its fashionable to name Rahman as your influence. And rightly so. He was indeed the one significant point of deflection in Indian film music that captured the attention of a large number of gen-next. Rahman has withstood the onslaught of many other conventional composers both in Hindi and Tamil since 1992. At the same time, conventional filmi music has continued to flourish in Hindi with astounding success stories like Nadeem Shravan and Jatin Lalit - alongside Rahman.

To be honest, I’m not the same dreamy-eyed fan of Rahman that I was in 1992. And, my friend Gopal Srinivasan, who I met online back in the late 90s, through the Yahoo Groups on Rahman that he manages with alarming devotion, knows this all too well. He’s perhaps the only person who may have seen the entire arc in my excitement vis-à-vis Rahman’s music. I have graduated to a state where I can confidently say that his music sucks sometimes (The Taj anthem?) and I’m quite content with that dispassionate mindset.

I do continue enjoying his music and would want to listen to it as soon as its released. But, the fact that I look forward to the music of even a Salim Sulaiman or Mithoon perhaps shows that Rahman’s task is far tougher these days. However, 15 years of this man’s music, in my opinion, has changed our idea of film music like very few composers’ work, before him. Taking names here is unfair to both Rahman’s creativity and the combined talent of the other composers in question, but I’m sure you know what I’m talking about.

My Top 5 Rahman soundtrack picks, in order of my personal preference!
1. Thiruda Thiruda (Tamil)
2. Yuva (Hindi)
3. Roja (Tamil)
4. Dil Se (Hindi)
5. Kaadhal Desam (Tamil)

The very-confusing music rights brouhaha

No Comments »

With the recent news about composing trio Shankar Ehsaan Loy getting to be music producers (for Johnny Gaddar) rather than just being music composers, I was wondering if they have achieved what even A.R.Rahman couldn’t - more so after that very public spat between Rahman and Farah Khan over Om shanti om’s music publishing rights. But, at least one write-up says that Rahman did indeed manage to get Aamir Khan to agree on sharing the music publishing rights for his home production, ‘Jaane tu ya jaane na’, directed by Abbas Tyrewalla. So, is Adlabs’ Pooja Shetty simply misinformed?

Keywords: Om shanti om, Karz, Shah Rukh Khan, Deepika Padukone, Shankar Mahadevan, Ehsaan Noorani, Vishal Shekhar

Defying logic or illogical opinions?

No Comments »

What’s this obsession with logic in the recently-released Sivaji? Every single Tamil weekly review adds a line saying that a particular scene defies logic. Examples quoted include the hawala transaction, Rajinikanth’s cable-cutting act (!), Rajinikanth resurrected after being declared dead etc. Is a puny (Think Dhanush!) hero fighting 15 guys logical…and to think, that’s been happening for ages now, in Tamil cinema. Cinema is a make-believe art with only a few directors treading the realistic path. Shankar perhaps adds scenes for the effect, not for the logic. Is it so hard for reviewers to accept this fact?

Keywords: Sivaji, Rajinkant, Logic, Illogical

Bollywood and the forgotten feeling called shame!

2 Comments »

We Indians have got used to all plagiarism in Bollywood, but when you’re premiering your scene-to-scene copied film in England - while the original starred one of UK’s biggest stars, how can you not be worried? Varun Bajaj, producer of The Train, lifted off the Hollywood film, Derailed (starring Clive Owen) has this to say, when IndiaFM asked him, “What exactly does the premiere at IIFA mean for the film?” - “…with around 300 journalists watching, the film would get an extensive coverage“. Hello! Isn’t that something worth speaking to your legal adviser and covering your sorry face in humiliation?

Keywords: Emraan Hashmi, Sayali Bhagat, Geeta Basra, Mithoon

Himesh and the love/hate dichotomy

11 Comments »

Quite a few people have mailed me with extreme annoyance and complete disbelief – ‘Why are you a member in both Himesh fans and Hate-Himesh groups at Orkut?’ Are we supposed to take a stand and join groups accordingly? I’m there in both groups only to understand how and why both sets of people react. I like some of Himesh’s soundtracks, but also hate many others. The question is not liking/ hating Himesh - it’s liking/ hating particular tracks of Himesh. For some very strange reason, many people mix both up beyond reason and end up being the quintessential Himesh fanatic!

Keywords: Himesh Reshammiya

keep looking »